Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

Person B scored 107 pts.

Person A scrored 90 pts.

Here is the problem though. Person A called the Commishes cell phone at 1130am on sunday to tell him that he was unable to get to a computer and to sub two of his players. The players he wanted subed were Heath Miller for LJ smith, and Keenan Mcardell for Hines ward. However because the commish was out of town and didnt listen to his messages he was unable to sub those players. If they had been subed player A would have scored 108, beating Person B.

So..who should be sided with? Should the commish side with A because he was left a message before the games started? or should the commish side with person B because this is just part of fantasy & person A could have easily called someone else and gotten them to do it?

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

I say tough [censored]...Player B wins

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

[ QUOTE ]
I say tough [censored]...Player B wins

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

Are you guys [censored] serious? If this is a friendly league (not just random dudes) and the guy had no computer access and called the commish beforehand to tell him is real starters then those should be his starters.

grow up and have some respect.

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

Person A. It's not close.

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Person B . It's not close.

[/ QUOTE ]

He had all week.

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Person B . It's not close.

[/ QUOTE ]

He had all week.

[/ QUOTE ]

if he called him friday, it should be retroactive. he called him SUNDAY night. [censored] that.

agree 100% with you madtown

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

no, he called him sunday morning, BEFORE THE GAMES HAD STARTED.

who cares if he had all week- maybe he had finals, maybe his dog died. the point is that he indicated who his starters were to the commish before the games began. if you're really that petty then you suck at life.

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

[ QUOTE ]
no, he called him sunday morning, BEFORE THE GAMES HAD STARTED.

who cares if he had all week- maybe he had finals, maybe his dog died. the point is that he indicated who his starters were to the commish before the games began. if you're really that petty then you suck at life.

[/ QUOTE ]

oops. I read PM. if he called him before the games, then I agree his players should have been started.

Re: Who should be sided with in this fantasy football situation?
 

Depends on if there's money on the line, and if it's major. If it's serious, than B wins. If it's a fun league, A wins.