Re: Follow up questions and comments
 

save up your money.... open up an online margin account when you get 2k.

Re: Starting Out
 

[ QUOTE ]

The US economy is doing pretty well isn't it? GDP rose 3.9% for the 3rd quarter. The Fed has been raising the interest rates because they feel the economy is recovering.

[/ QUOTE ]

1) Growth in "GDP" is not the product of increased wealth or productivity. Economic activity is being propped up by massive consumer spending (which makes up most of the GDP) fueled by credit card debt and home equity financing, which will die down as interest rates rise and more high paying jobs are moved offshore.

2) 3.9% growth in GDP by itself (or whatever doctored statistic they are putting out) is meaningless if your currency is being devalued at a rate faster than that.

3) Rising interest rates serve to slow down economic activity, not speed it up (this is a very fundamental concept by the way). Particularly when you are coming down from the biggest debt bubble in the history of the United States.

4) I don't have a very high opinion of the federal reserve or what they have to say about the economy. I prefer to rely on my own research and analysis.

This is a very complicated topic and I can't really do justice to it in a few paragraphs. The short answer is - no, the US economy is not alright. There are certainly other countries in the world doing much better and growing at a much faster rate.

Re: Starting Out
 

[ QUOTE ]
1) Growth in "GDP" is not the product of increased wealth or productivity. Economic activity is being propped up by massive consumer spending (which makes up most of the GDP) fueled by credit card debt and home equity financing, which will die down as interest rates rise and more high paying jobs are moved offshore.

[/ QUOTE ]

Of course economic activity has everything to do with consumption. Again the long end of the yield curve is actually lower in yield now than at the start of 2004. My understanding is that the net loss of jobs outsourcing is more or less insignificant.

[ QUOTE ]
2) 3.9% growth in GDP by itself (or whatever doctored statistic they are putting out) is meaningless if your currency is being devalued at a rate faster than that.


[/ QUOTE ]

Exchange rates fluctuate. The Fed has adopted a more restrictive monetary policy and the US $ index, the DXY, is right at multi year lows which would suggest to me that at least a short term bounce in the US $ is immenent. Fundamental factors affecting the US $ such as the current account deficit are problematic though. I've noticed that the price of a barrel of oil has fallen a lot from it's highs which would indicate that indeed a more restrictive monetary policy from the Fed is being accepted by the markets.

[ QUOTE ]
3) Rising interest rates serve to slow down economic activity, not speed it up (this is a very fundamental concept by the way). Particularly when you are coming down from the biggest debt bubble in the history of the United States.

[/ QUOTE ]

To be sure about interest rates. As far as debt bubble let's define that in quantitative terms and I'm not sure what you mean by coming down. Do you mean the bubble is subsiding?

[ QUOTE ]
4) I don't have a very high opinion of the federal reserve or what they have to say about the economy. I prefer to rely on my own research and analysis.

[/ QUOTE ]

Parsing Greenspeak is always problematic [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img].

You make some good points but I'd say that extreme doom and gloom outcomes are low probability events and that using a crystal ball to predict markets is something that is dicey at best.

Re: Starting Out
 

open a brokerage account with fidelity or vangard. put money into money market account until you find a stock you like. then buy that and hold it until you find a reason to sell. dont put alot into berk. as its future will depend on the life of an old man. get as much a year as you can into ira type things. as you get older the vast amount of investments will act as its own mutual fund and you will be diversified on your own. dont buy anthing with fees attached. just buy the stocks yourself generally.
but your best investment will be your home and what you know best.

Re: Starting Out
 

There are a lot of things wrong with the US economy right now, but my basic premise is this:

The economic "recovery" has been fueled by a massive consumer debt bubble. The federal reserve has inflated this bubble further by continuing to lend money at artificially low interest rates (they have been lending money at negative interest rates in real terms for several years now). Look at this graph for a second...

Credit Market Debt as % of GDP

This type of economic "growth" is unsustainable. Even with interest rates at historical lows, bankruptcies, forclosures, and missed mortgage payments are at all time highs. These trends will only accelerate as interest rates continue to rise and wages continue to decline. When consumer spending collapses, so too will the US economy.

I cannot state my case any clearer than that.

Like another poster said, when it comes to investing, I only play AA. And the US as a whole is certainly no AA.

That's not to say you won't be able to make money in stocks. I think debt collectors and predatory paycheck loan shops will make out like bandits...

Re: Starting Out
 

[ QUOTE ]
3) Rising interest rates serve to slow down economic activity

[/ QUOTE ]

Exactly, and Greenspan is willing to risk slowing down the economy by raising rates. He wouldn't raise rates in a recession, because he wouldn't risk slowing down the economy further.

Re: Starting Out
 

[ QUOTE ]

Exactly, and Greenspan is willing to risk slowing down the economy by raising rates. He wouldn't raise rates in a recession, because he wouldn't risk slowing down the economy further.

[/ QUOTE ]

I hate to be the one to break this to you, but Greenspan is an idiot. Giving away money to "fix" the economy as he has done is a short term solution to a long term problem.

If you think our economy is built on solid foundations and that rising interest rates are bullish for stocks, then I will just have to respectfully disagree. [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]

Re: Starting Out
 

[ QUOTE ]
If you think our economy is built on solid foundations and that rising interest rates are bullish for stocks,

[/ QUOTE ]

Interest rates are still low, home mortgage rates are low, and the Fed rate is still low.

You don't think the world's largest ecomony is built on a solid foundation?

Also, you talk about credit debt - do you realize those figures include any credit card debt? That means credit card debt that gets wiped clean every month shows the same as long term credit debt, like mortgages and car loans.

Who pays cash for anything anymore, doesn't everyone put the bill on there card? So this number should be much higher than it's historically been because most items are paid for on credit. Hopefully you can understand how that radically changes the value of this metric.