Two Plus Two Older Archives

Two Plus Two Older Archives (http://archives2.twoplustwo.com/index.php)
-   Psychology (http://archives2.twoplustwo.com/forumdisplay.php?f=24)
-   -   Dating someone bi-polar (http://archives2.twoplustwo.com/showthread.php?t=398939)

TomCollins 12-15-2005 11:32 AM

Dating someone bi-polar
 
Anyone had this expirience?

Exsubmariner 12-15-2005 11:38 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
No,
But I once was sleeping with a stripper who had multiple personalities. She would wake up in the middle of the night and ask me my name. I would tell her and then ask what hers was. By the time I met the 5th one, I decided it was time to go far, far away. It's too bad, too, because she was a great piece of ass.

My advice, end it now.

AlanBostick 12-15-2005 12:24 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I've never dated anyone whom I knew either to be bipolar or to have multiple personalities. I do, however, have both sorts of people as friends. As far as I can tell, the two conditions are very different, and advising someone to break up with an S.O. of one sort based on an experience with someone of the other seems strange to me.

It's sort of like saying, "I used to go out with a ski bum, and it didn't work, so I advise you to break up with your poker-playing boyfriend."

AlanBostick 12-15-2005 12:26 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I've no bipolar dating experience, but I do have friends who are bipolar.

Is the S.O. in question Type I or Type II?

Autocratic 12-15-2005 12:50 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I had a good friend who was bi-polar. It ruined our friendship. I actually never really asked her about it, so I don't know the type or anything, but over time she began to think I had plotted to end a friendship of hers and said she never wanted to talk to me again. I haven't really talked to her in two years (we had been pretty close for 3 years before that).

12-15-2005 12:53 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
My brother's girlfriend is bipolar.

It's a pain in the neck but with some patience, you can deal.

Make sure they take their meds and life is so much easier.

Of course, my brother's girlfriend's meds make children a non viable option if that is something that matters to you.

noggindoc 12-15-2005 12:59 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]


Make sure they take their meds and life is so much easier.


[/ QUOTE ]

This is quite true. Of course this whole thing is going to depend on the severity of the bipolar disorder (is it Bipolar I or Bipolar II, etc.). If it is Bipolar I and is severe, there will be serious challenges within the relationship. It can happen though, everyone needs love!

TomCollins 12-15-2005 01:10 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
It's still real early, so I figure it would be best to know what I'd be dealing with before anything significant happened. I suspected something was up when she said something like "I'd have to have an abortion because of the medicine I'm on". I'm pretty patient, so if it's just that, I'm not concerned. She's got a few other issues I learned about, but she's getting help and taking medicine. She did suggest she plans on having kids and all, I don't know if that means going off the medicine for a while or what.

I'm pretty ignorant, and my only knowledge of it is an ex-gf I had who's dad had it and later killed himself. I think she might have had it as well, but that didn't last too long for other reasons. She's a pretty cool chick, just wanted to know what the hell I'm getting into ahead of time.

rocketlaunch 12-15-2005 02:27 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I dated a chick who was bipolar. All I can say is that if this girl is 1/10th as much of a lunatic as the girl I dated, you should run, far, faaaarrr away.

Things started out normal enough, but then she began getting super-paranoid and very accusatory. Her mood swings were unbelievable--one day she'd be all happy and outgoing, and the next she'd be depressed and miserable. In each case, it was to such an extreme that she practically had a completely different personality. Things that she liked in one mood she would absolutely hate in the other, and it was up to me to always figure out which person I was dealing with on a daily basis, lest I piss her off to no end.

It all seems tame when I describe now, but really it was pure insanity. The suicide threats and threats of violence one day, and then the person who couldn't so much as hurt a fly the next day. All with constant lies and denials and selfishness.

There were days when she was a normal person, and those days her "true" nature shined through (a very good person, I think), but much of the time it was nothing short of insanity. She had definitely learned to act "normal" in front of most people, but once you knew her well and she had to be around you more than on a passing basis, there was no hiding it.

At the very least, I'd recommend that your girl staying on medication be a prerequisite to your guys' continued dating. The few bipolar people I've known and the one girl I dated (and from what I hear, bipolar people in general) have a tendency to go on meds, feel somewhat better and then go off them thinking they don't need them any more. Dealing with a seriously bipolar person not on meds is like dealing with a pitbull with its nuts in a tourniquet--all you can do is stay out of the way and hope you don't get hurt.

JackThree 12-15-2005 02:47 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
i am bipolar, but i was just recently diagnosed, previous to medication, i was nuts. constant stress on my girlfriend, we finally broke up because of it

12-15-2005 02:51 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]
I dated a chick who was bipolar. All I can say is that if this girl is 1/10th as much of a lunatic as the girl I dated, you should run, far, faaaarrr away.

Things started out normal enough, but then she began getting super-paranoid and very accusatory. Her mood swings were unbelievable--one day she'd be all happy and outgoing, and the next she'd be depressed and miserable. In each case, it was to such an extreme that she practically had a completely different personality. Things that she liked in one mood she would absolutely hate in the other, and it was up to me to always figure out which person I was dealing with on a daily basis, lest I piss her off to no end.

It all seems tame when I describe now, but really it was pure insanity. The suicide threats and threats of violence one day, and then the person who couldn't so much as hurt a fly the next day. All with constant lies and denials and selfishness.

There were days when she was a normal person, and those days her "true" nature shined through (a very good person, I think), but much of the time it was nothing short of insanity. She had definitely learned to act "normal" in front of most people, but once you knew her well and she had to be around you more than on a passing basis, there was no hiding it.

At the very least, I'd recommend that your girl staying on medication be a prerequisite to your guys' continued dating. The few bipolar people I've known and the one girl I dated (and from what I hear, bipolar people in general) have a tendency to go on meds, feel somewhat better and then go off them thinking they don't need them any more. Dealing with a seriously bipolar person not on meds is like dealing with a pitbull with its nuts in a tourniquet--all you can do is stay out of the way and hope you don't get hurt.

[/ QUOTE ]

Almost exactly what I endured for two years. She accused me of cheating on her with every woman I knew (including the mother of one of my chess students.) Of course, she could hang out with any guy she wanted. She would switch moods on a dime - all happy and lovey-dovey, then BAM I'm stupid she's stupid the whole world is stupid I think I'll kill myself. Constant guilt trips. Sometimes I got scared because something would set her off and she'd start hitting herself on the head. Of course, she also had relationship issues...can't imagine why.

The hard part was she could shape up just enough to keep me interested...promises of change and whatever. Never happened - actually it got worse. Eventually I realized it was only worth it so I can appreciate sane girls.

EDIT:Just saw the raising kids part. I dated another girl who was clinically depressed, and one day we were talking about the woman who drowned her kids in the tub. She told me that she could see herself doing that. Scared the S@#$ out of me. Too bad, she's a pretty and otherwise fun girl...although we'd have to break plans a lot because she was having an episode.

ScottieK

JackThree 12-15-2005 02:54 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]
She would switch moods on a dime - all happy and lovey-dovey, then BAM I'm stupid she's stupid the whole world is stupid I think I'll kill myself.

[/ QUOTE ]

those were the days....

rocketlaunch 12-15-2005 03:12 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]

Almost exactly what I endured for two years. She accused me of cheating on her with every woman I knew (including the mother of one of my chess students.) Of course, she could hang out with any guy she wanted. She would switch moods on a dime - all happy and lovey-dovey, then BAM I'm stupid she's stupid the whole world is stupid I think I'll kill myself. Constant guilt trips. Sometimes I got scared because something would set her off and she'd start hitting herself on the head. Of course, she also had relationship issues...can't imagine why.

The hard part was she could shape up just enough to keep me interested...promises of change and whatever. Never happened - actually it got worse. Eventually I realized it was only worth it so I can appreciate sane girls.

EDIT:Just saw the raising kids part. I dated another girl who was clinically depressed, and one day we were talking about the woman who drowned her kids in the tub. She told me that she could see herself doing that. Scared the S@#$ out of me. Too bad, she's a pretty and otherwise fun girl...although we'd have to break plans a lot because she was having an episode.

ScottieK

[/ QUOTE ]

Ding ding ding. I was talking to a female friend of mine at a party once and my bipolar gf came over and started yelling making a huge scene saying I was about to go cheat on her with that girl--nevermind the fact that my gf was obviously right there and my friend's bf was right there, too. Everyone there stopped whatever they were doing and just stared at the four of us (the bf of course came over interested to know who this guy who was supposedly going to hook up with his gf was). That was a lovely scene, and only one of about a million just crazy episodes in a real f'ed up relationship--I could literally give a dozen more, but I really don't even like remembering all of them.

Of course I'd want to leave her but then it was, "oh I"m sorry, I screwed up, I won't do it again, I'm trying, please don't leave wah wah" and of course she was hot enough and absolutely dynamite in bed, so I was the sucker who kept going back for more.

I'm still getting over the emotional damage from that relationship, and it's nearly three years later.

Not to discourage you or anything, OP, but you deserve to know the truth.

TomCollins 12-15-2005 04:20 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
That's why I ask. I have no idea what I might be getting into.

Burno 12-15-2005 06:08 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
If you are stable it can work. Two erratic personalities can easily fall in love, but will have great difficulty remaining together.

Bi-Polar in a great many cases can be minimized and in some cases eliminated with a proper exploration and understanding of one's mind. Meds do help but many cause significant withdrawal and their can be some crazy mood swings if they are changed. Therapy is where it's at, but it has to be often and consistent enough to be effective.

The biggest key, I swear, is to severely curtail the use of alcohol and narcotics. Often they are used to cope with the downswings or celebrate the upswings and they end up making the frequency and intensity of the swings so much worse. Plus, combining drugs or just alcohol with Bipolar meds just makes people loopy.

12-15-2005 07:44 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
It's highly unfortunate that many of you believe people can be captured by a psychodiagnostic label. Really, these sweeping generalizations about people with 'bipolar disorder,' are inaccurate, unfair and perpetuate unnecessary stereotypes.

Many people with bipolar disease are very productive, effective and highly likeable. I have bipolar disease (and Aspergar's with OCD) and work full-time, am not sexually promiscuous, do not use illegal drugs, am not highly impulsive nor psychotic.

Also, I want to explain something to you about the medications typically used to treat bipolar (and other serious brain diseases). A lack of insight is not always the cause of medication non-compliance. Often times the drugs themselves have extremely unpleasant and dangerous side effects. Many often cause irreversible, permanent neurological damage resembling Parkinson's (TD or Tardive Dyskinesia). A sample of undesired side effects (depending on the class of medication) may be blurred vision, nausea, extreme anxiety and agitation, tremors, GI upset, sweating, restless leg syndrome, twitches, involuntary movements, etc. There is often a serious cost-benefit analysis and it's not always irrational to resist being medicated (especially if you have a hypersensitivity to certain drugs such as an affinity for extrapyramidal reactions).

JeffreyREBT "Wherein I don't promise to make you rich without trying, or even trying very hard; I do promise to say things that will make you FEEL rich."

chesspain 12-15-2005 08:21 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]
If you are stable it can work. Two erratic personalities can easily fall in love, but will have great difficulty remaining together.

[/ QUOTE ]

One stable person is only half of the formula. If the partner is very unstable, the relationship is going to be severely challenged regardless of how normal the other individual might be.



[ QUOTE ]
Bi-Polar Disorder in a great many cases can be minimized and in some cases eliminated with a proper exploration and understanding of one's mind.

[/ QUOTE ]

False. Bipolar Disorder is a brain illness. It cannot be eliminated with psychotherapy--although therapy can help one to learn how to make better choices, how to cope with the mood swings, how to recognize the need to ask for a reassessment of one's medication regimen, etc.




[ QUOTE ]
Meds do help but many cause significant withdrawal and their can be some crazy mood swings if they are changed. Therapy is where it's at, but it has to be often and consistent enough to be effective.

[/ QUOTE ]

I'ld say that meds + therapy is where it's at...and I'm a psychologist, so my bias should be with therapy--except that I know that therapy will be insufficient with moderate to severe cases of Bipolar Disorder.




[ QUOTE ]
The biggest key, I swear, is to severely curtail the use of alcohol and narcotics. Often they are used to cope with the downswings or celebrate the upswings and they end up making the frequency and intensity of the swings so much worse. Plus, combining drugs or just alcohol with Bipolar meds just makes people loopy.

[/ QUOTE ]

This is 100% correct.

bobman0330 12-15-2005 09:10 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I did. It sucked hard. Cruel to say, but odds are you'd be better off not getting involved.

Burno 12-16-2005 12:43 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I will, of course, defer to chesspain, as I am not a psychologist, but I do work in the field(special needs) and have a degree. I do, however, have some terrific insight into the Bi-Polar world, for a variety of reasons.

Couple questions for Chess.

1. What % of individuals diagnosed as Bi-polar would you estimate are actually bi-polar?

2. What are your thoughts on the use of marijuana to regualte mood swings?

chesspain 12-16-2005 01:03 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
[ QUOTE ]
Couple questions for Chess.

1. What % of individuals diagnosed as Bi-polar would you estimate are actually bi-polar?

[/ QUOTE ]

I have no idea



[ QUOTE ]
2. What are your thoughts on the use of marijuana to regualte mood swings?

[/ QUOTE ]

Although I personally believe that marijuana or alcohol can be pleasant and fairly benign when used by reasonably healthy individuals in moderation, I also believe that the chronic use of either/both by individuals with major mood disorders tends to lead, in general, to worsenned depression in the long-run.

12-16-2005 01:35 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
My sister is bi-poler, and my advice is it depends on how severe it is for her (or him?) and how calm and level-headed you are

I've always had a good relationshop with my sister, but I am a very calm person (maybe because of this?). It can be hard sometimes, like when they do something ridiculous, can you blame them? Is it their fault, or is it out of their control and therefor not their fault? I dunno.

For example, suppose they request something ridiculous. You can either:

1) comply, but risk giving him/her the impression that they 'deserve' to get what they want whenever they ask for it.

2) not comply, but risk infuriating them. Is it worth it?

I've been faced with this choice many times. Obviously each situation is a little different, like if she says "pass me that fork" you probably should, but if she says "cook all my meals and clean my house every day" you should probably not.

But yeah, if during one of their bad moods you can keep calm, talk in a normal voice, and think logically (not forgetting their condition) then you got a chance I reckon

JackThree 12-16-2005 04:22 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
i love lamictal <3

whiskeytown 12-16-2005 06:06 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
No, I have not dated anyone bipolar.

I have found however that being bipolar and depressive brings down your chances a bit.

RB

12-16-2005 07:14 AM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
if bi-polar is anything like bi-sexual you might be able to get a hot 3 way going

12-16-2005 08:00 PM

Re: Dating someone bi-polar
 
I personally wouldn't allow bipolar disorder to automatically disqualify a potential mate. However, I would advise you to be cognizant of special needs related to her illness. If you're truly interested you might start out by educating yourself on the illness. Having insight will enable you to more effectively deal with everyday challenges or even a crisis. I think your mileage will vary based on how willing you are to invest time and energy being an active participant in the management of the diease.

These considerations will become even more imperative if you move from casual dating to a serious intimate relationship. Then you will likely find it highly beneficial (if not absolutely necessary) to be proactive in the treatment of her disease. For example, you might drive her to scheduled appointments, attend medical appointments together, remind her to take her medications, call the doctor if you notice her becoming manic, etc. Is it worth expending this much effort? Only you can make this assessment based on your personal appraisal of your relationship's value.

JeffreyREBT "Wherein I don't promise to make you rich without trying, or even trying very hard; I do promise to say things that will make you feel rich."


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.