Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

Can we get a list of best albums of the year? I'm too lazy to look it up and I copied all my ripped CDs to a new HD in January of 2004. I can only tell if something was 2004, 2005 or <2004.

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
Your choice is basically gauranteed to win because most people don't remember when music came out and won't have an opinion of their own.

[/ QUOTE ]

Agreed. Call me a nit, but the OP putting in his own opinion in the original post causes a lot of bias in the poll results. It happens way too often.

Nonetheless, Radiohead's Hail to the Thief came out in 2003, so I'm going with that.

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
Seriously, who are these bands?

I don't even think my 20 closest friends could name any of these people besides talking heads/modest mouse.

[/ QUOTE ]
I was inconsistent with naming the band or album. Edited so you will recognize more.

GoT

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
[music elitist]
Your friends listen to shi[/i]tty music.
[/music elitist]

[/ QUOTE ]

Its not that we sit around and listen to the latest Maroon 5 CD. Most of my friends like classic rock (or older rap), so obviously it would be hard to know who any of these bands are. Either way, are these bands actually well known or do only trendy music snobs listen to them?

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

wikipedia has solid lists of albums that came out in any given year (2003 here).

i went with 2003 for the following:
meadowlands (the wrens)
absolution (muse)
deloused in the comatorium (mars volta)
hail to the theif (radiohead)
castaways and cutouts (the decembrists)
two conversations (appleseed cast)
the earth is not a cold dead place (explosions in the sky)
think tank (blur)
you forgot it in people (broken social scene)

probably forgot some. 2004 was a close second for me.

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
do only trendy music snobs listen to them?

[/ QUOTE ]


Bingo, and I am one.

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[music elitist]
Your friends listen to shi[/i]tty music.
[/music elitist]

[/ QUOTE ]

Its not that we sit around and listen to the latest Maroon 5 CD. Most of my friends like classic rock (or older rap), so obviously it would be hard to know who any of these bands are. Either way, are these bands actually well known or do only trendy music snobs listen to them?

[/ QUOTE ]

To be honest, I actually figured that was the case, because most people on here who ask "who the [censored] are these bands?" in OOT music threads just don't seem like the Top 40 crappy rock/pop types, you included. Nothing wrong with classic rock, rap, etc -- it's just that the best music being made right now when it comes to rock and pop are from indie bands.

It's hard to gauge how common it is for people to know these bands, because most of them are on (or started on) indie labels and thus don't get radio play other than on college stations. So you have to seek them out a little bit, and the main demographic seems to be college kids.

In my case, I'd say about 50% of my friends would recognize a lot of the bands listed here, maybe more. Whether or not they're trendy music snobs depends on what that means. For example, whenever one of these threads starts up, us trendy music snobs are quick to point out that our favorite all-time bands are still usually classic rock and pop -- Beatles, Dylan, Led Zeppelin, The Doors, etc etc.

If being a "trendy music snob" means that I think most of the best music being made right now isn't being played on MTV/Clear Channel, then yeah, I am. If it means that I feel superior because most people haven't heard of these bands and I have, then not really. In fact, I hate people who stop liking indie bands that get somewhat popular (see: Modest Mouse).

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

[ QUOTE ]
are these bands actually well known or do only trendy music snobs listen to them?

[/ QUOTE ]
Eh, most of my friends would know 90% of that list so I don't think of any of them as obscure really. Which may make you think I'm a music snob, but it's a hard sell considering my roomie came home today to find me listening to Kelly Clarkson. [img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

GoT

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

All the music snobs love Kelly Clakrson.

2005 in a walk, btw.

Re: Best year of the new millenium for music
 

Hmm, I don't know the exact year when most albums came out except a few. I know Lateralus came out in 2001 and someone pointed out Hail to the Thief came out in 2003. So both years would work for me but I'm going to go with 2001.