Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Big argument at work today. You know that the colts have some salary cap issues right now. If you had to decide, who would you keep? Marvin Harrison or Ed. James?

Thanks,

Indy

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

no... instead rework Stokley's horrible contract.

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Given that I had to keep one or the other, I would keep Harrison. James has had a lot of carries and a lot of hits, and I think that makes him the riskier of the two.

I think it is possible that Indy doesn't re-sign either at the end of the season.

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Harrison is 6 years older than Edge. He is arguably not even the best receiver on the team at this point and will almost certainly not be going forward.

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

[ QUOTE ]
Harrison is 6 years older than Edge. He is arguably not even the best receiver on the team at this point and will almost certainly not be going forward.

[/ QUOTE ]

Edge easy.

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Edge. A shorter deal though, as RBs have a short shelf life. With their D doing so well, I could see them taking a shot at a WR in the draft. No better way to develop a WR than to build his confidence with lots of TD catches from Manning. (well, it works in Madden)

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Edge

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

[ QUOTE ]
Big argument at work today. You know that the colts have some salary cap issues right now. If you had to decide, who would you keep? Marvin Harrison or Ed. James?

Thanks,

Indy

[/ QUOTE ]

They signed Marvin to a long term deal two years ago. This isn't a choice that anyone but you and your colleagues are making.

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

He didn't say otherwise.

I love when people respond to chastise and correct things that were never said in the first place.

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Big argument at work today. You know that the colts have some salary cap issues right now. If you had to decide, who would you keep? Marvin Harrison or Ed. James?

Thanks,

Indy

[/ QUOTE ]

They signed Marvin to a long term deal two years ago. This isn't a choice that anyone but you and your colleagues are making.

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: Please help me settle a football argument-Colts
 

Fair enough. I wanted to point out that this wasn't a real situation, if OP thought it was.

Anyway, Edge is the clear "keeper."