Brett Favre
 

Where would you slot the current Brett Favre among the current NFL starting QBs?

Re: Brett Favre
 

Top third. He's the only reason the Packers have been close in games this year.

Re: Brett Favre
 

I can understand the arguments for top third or middle third, but anyone who says bottom third is insane.

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
I can understand the arguments for top third or middle third, but anyone who says bottom third is insane.

[/ QUOTE ]

Agreed. What 20 guys are better?

Re: Brett Favre
 

he can be a real liability with his inaccuracy and he throws a lot of picks, but when they pack needs to win, he gets it done. (monday night excluded)

Re: Brett Favre
 

and the 3 games before that.

craig

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
he can be a real liability with his inaccuracy and he throws a lot of picks, but when they pack needs to win, he gets it done. (monday night excluded)

[/ QUOTE ]

I'll agree that he throws a lot of picks. But A LOT of them are a result of his recievers not being able to run the right routes, fight for balls and stay healthy.

Re: Brett Favre
 

I voted bottom third. That's simply me trying to create cosmic balance and him being so highly overrated by any and all announcers. I really think he's about an average quarterback.

He tries to play outside himself too much. Sometimes he comes up big, a lot of the time he screws his team over by making dumb plays and throwing a lot of picks.

Re: Brett Favre
 

Bottom third should have been bottom 3.

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
I voted bottom third. That's simply me trying to create cosmic balance and him being so highly overrated by any and all announcers. I really think he's about an average quarterback.

He tries to play outside himself too much. Sometimes he comes up big, a lot of the time he screws his team over by making dumb plays and throwing a lot of picks.

[/ QUOTE ]

Can you read my mind or something?