huge FF trade offer
 

my team currently is:

start qb,2wr,2rb,k,te,def

i have

Palmer
Vick

Edge
Caddillac
K.Jones
Pittman

Harrison
TJ Houshmanzedah
Mi. Clayton
Joe Jerrovicious
Stokley

Tony G

Scobee
Reed

Colts D
Jets D

I have been offered the following trade from a 1-4 team in my division that i have to play twice more, I am tied for div lead at 3-2.

I get

Cullpepper, Larry Fitzgerald, Steven Jackson
for
Palmer, Joe Jerrovicous, Edge

Pretty standard scoring but a little TD heavy vs. yardage. 6 pt all TDs (incl. passing)
9 pt TDs for 20-39
12 pts for 40+
(so fitzgerald might have a little more value than in normal leagues)

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

dont know about the trade, but that TD scoring is very stupid.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
dont know about the trade, but that TD scoring is very stupid.

[/ QUOTE ]

i like it...makes you look for big play guys. it can get quite flukey, though.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

do not do this trade. edge is too good even if palmer falls off.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
do not do this trade. edge is too good even if palmer falls off.

[/ QUOTE ]

im not so sure. having fitz at #2 WR is a lot better than TJ Hooker. And S Jackson is still pretty good.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
do not do this trade. edge is too good even if palmer falls off.

[/ QUOTE ]

im not so sure. having fitz at #2 WR is a lot better than TJ Hooker. And S Jackson is still pretty good.

[/ QUOTE ]

michael clayton will get some #'s really soon

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
do not do this trade. edge is too good even if palmer falls off.

[/ QUOTE ]

im not so sure. having fitz at #2 WR is a lot better than TJ Hooker. And S Jackson is still pretty good.

[/ QUOTE ]

michael clayton will get some #'s really soon

[/ QUOTE ]

too bad he will likely be on my bench.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

Looks to me like you are downgrading two positions (QB and RB) and upgrading one (WR). Thats not usually a good exchange.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

I don't like it. I don't see many ways where Culpepper has a better year than Carson Palmer. With Martz gone Jackson might actually see that ball, but you can't be sure and the Edge is always going to be better. Larry Fitzgerald and Joe Jerovicous will be about equal for the next few weeks and you can always mix and match that second WR spot it is not worth giving up a better QB and RB.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

1) I agree with the others. Looks like your potential upside is minimal and your potential downside is huge. I wouldn't do it.

2) I'm amazed you managed to come very close to the spelling of Houshamnadassdfajfda right and absolutely butcher Jurevicius.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
I wouldn't do it.

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

How many teams are in your league?

I don't like the trade.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

[ QUOTE ]
Looks to me like you are downgrading two positions (QB and RB) and upgrading one (WR). Thats not usually a good exchange.

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

This is a horrible HORRIBLE trade offer. Your team is stacked, don't do it. Caulpepper is showing his #'s are not nearly as good without Randy Moss. Anyone on the vikings is radioactive with the problems that team is having.

Don't do that trade.

Re: huge FF trade offer
 

i ended up backing off, but he countered w/ this:

edge
JJ
Jets D

SJack
Fitz
Panthers D

I took it.