Pink Floyd Rules
 

The Final Cut

Best Album EVER. anyone else agree?

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

it is a good album... Don't think I'd call it their best though... Partial to Echoes myself.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

i like dark side of teh moon.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

how's that apple?

As for the final cut, I think it is a beautifully put together album, not unlike the Wall in that every song flows naturally into the next and almost like chronologically telling a story. They are incedible artists.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

[ QUOTE ]
how's that apple?

[/ QUOTE ]


it's a bell pepper, actually, and it's faaaantastic. [img]/images/graemlins/smirk.gif[/img]

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

[ QUOTE ]
Partial to Echoes myself.

[/ QUOTE ]

I don't think compilation albums should be counted in best album discussions

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

listen to animals, then try this thread again

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

[ QUOTE ]

listen to animals, then try this thread again

[/ QUOTE ]

I have every Pink Floyd album known to man ( I think ) and I have to agree Animals is incredible. But The Final Cut has the almost singular quality ( besides the Wall) that the whole is greater than the sum of the parts.

Vlorg

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

Oh jeez, I do that. I'm thinking Meddle on which the final song is Echoes. I am known to call The Final Cut, Post War Dream.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

Much like The Wall, The Final Cut is really a Roger Waters solo album disguised as a Pink Floyd album. Not sayin' both aren't great, and I'm not sayin' the other members didn't contribute. However, they really cannot compare to Dark Side of The Moon, Wish You Were Here or Animals.


JunkHead

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

[ QUOTE ]
listen to animals, then try this thread again

[/ QUOTE ]


thank you for being the voice of experience

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

</font><blockquote><font class="small">En respuesta a:</font><hr />
listen to animals, then try this thread again

[/ QUOTE ]

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

Atom Heart Mother
.
.
&lt;all their other albums&gt;
.
.
The Final Cut

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

Wish You Were Here is obviously the correct answer, anything else is just plain wrong. Honorable mention to Animals though.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

animals is far better and likely the best at least imo.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

</font><blockquote><font class="small">En réponse à:</font><hr />
The Final Cut

Best Album EVER. anyone else agree?

[/ QUOTE ]
I'd be surprised if this was on anyone's list of top ten Pink Floyd albums, let alone best albums of all time. I guess it's better than Ummagumma.

Re: Pink Floyd Rules
 

I am partial to Animals myself. Although, Saucerful of Secrets is pretty high on my list. Final Cut, close to the bottom.