Brett Favre
 

Where would you slot the current Brett Favre among the current NFL starting QBs?

Re: Brett Favre
 

Top third. He's the only reason the Packers have been close in games this year.

Re: Brett Favre
 

I can understand the arguments for top third or middle third, but anyone who says bottom third is insane.

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
I can understand the arguments for top third or middle third, but anyone who says bottom third is insane.

[/ QUOTE ]

Agreed. What 20 guys are better?

Re: Brett Favre
 

he can be a real liability with his inaccuracy and he throws a lot of picks, but when they pack needs to win, he gets it done. (monday night excluded)

Re: Brett Favre
 

and the 3 games before that.

craig

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
he can be a real liability with his inaccuracy and he throws a lot of picks, but when they pack needs to win, he gets it done. (monday night excluded)

[/ QUOTE ]

I'll agree that he throws a lot of picks. But A LOT of them are a result of his recievers not being able to run the right routes, fight for balls and stay healthy.

Re: Brett Favre
 

I voted bottom third. That's simply me trying to create cosmic balance and him being so highly overrated by any and all announcers. I really think he's about an average quarterback.

He tries to play outside himself too much. Sometimes he comes up big, a lot of the time he screws his team over by making dumb plays and throwing a lot of picks.

Re: Brett Favre
 

Bottom third should have been bottom 3.

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
I voted bottom third. That's simply me trying to create cosmic balance and him being so highly overrated by any and all announcers. I really think he's about an average quarterback.

He tries to play outside himself too much. Sometimes he comes up big, a lot of the time he screws his team over by making dumb plays and throwing a lot of picks.

[/ QUOTE ]

Can you read my mind or something?

Re: Brett Favre
 

[ QUOTE ]
Bottom third should have been bottom 3.

[/ QUOTE ]

Please.

Re: Brett Favre
 

Read this

...and never pay attention to an NLTroll post in the Sporting Events forum again

Re: Brett Favre
 

It all makes perfect sense to me now.

Re: Brett Favre
 

If you read the beginning of this thread you'd see that the pick myth was basically debunked.

I"m also disappointed that no one has mentioned the Super Bowl. He won. And not in the way Trent Dilfer won.

Re: Brett Favre
 

Favre's one of those boom or bust guys that lives dangerously. When things go right (most of the time) it's spectacular. When he doesn't have any help whatsoever, things go very very wrong.

He's an exceptional quarterback with no help and lots of years and hits piling up. I say middle third.