Re: \"Do you want me to call?\"
 

[ QUOTE ]
So according to Roberts Rules of poker and TDA rules, even the hand is heads up and one player is all in, is it legal for the other player to show his and and ask this question?

Player A is all in, everyone folds to player B who is the only other player in the pot. Can he flip his cards and ask this question?

I know it's a different story in some other cards games, like Five draw but what about in HE?

JMB

[/ QUOTE ]

I don't think it is illegal. According to the TDA you can't show your cards with action pending. However, I would interpret that to mean other player's action. Since the only remaining player is all-in and has no further action to take I would say that player B can make this move.

However, I would be really careful about angle shooting in this situation. Typically, unless he's said call to an all-in, flipping your cards face up on the table is a fold. So, if he's not hanging on to his cards when he shows them, this could be an angle shot, player A starts to celebrate thinking he's folded and then player B says call. Or perhaps player A interprets it as a call of his all-in and reacts in an obvious way. It's not as likely if Player B merely shows as opposed to flipping them up, that player A will think he's made a binding decision.

--Zetack