Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

Or was it the most talented at an instrument?

(And songwriting just helps)

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

Edward Van Halen

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

How about producers?

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Or was it the most talented at an instrument?

(And songwriting just helps)

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

[ QUOTE ]
How about producers?

[/ QUOTE ]


Then it might not be close.

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Or was it the most talented at an instrument?

(And songwriting just helps)

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes

[/ QUOTE ]

Ahh... then no, Richards doesnt deserve mention.

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

[ QUOTE ]
How about producers?

[/ QUOTE ]

Just instrument-playing musicians, with songwriting skills as a bonus for tie-breakers.

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

Did Eric Clapton ever sing?

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Did Eric Clapton ever sing?

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes.

http://us.ent1.yimg.com/images.launc...5/10465310.jpg

Re: Best rock/pop musician who never sang?
 

Well, with Eric Clapton out of the way, I really can't see how this award doesn't go to Milli Vanilli.