Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

Half-Life 2 is so much better than anything out there. Yes it deserves its spot.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

[ QUOTE ]
Is Half-Life 2 really that revolutionary?

[/ QUOTE ]

In my opinion, yes.
But obviously not as much so as War2.

It's tough when you rank games of different genres against each other, though.

No doubt there was, and will continue to be, much disagreement about this list from just about everyone. [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

Wizardry 6, 7, 8 all should be up there.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

Some ridiculous inclusions (Beavis & Butt-Head in Virtual Stupidity - give me a break) and some glaring omissions (none of the Final Fantasy games, Tetris, Halo, no Mario games, Techmo Bowl just off the top of my head). I would bet most of the publishers on the list advertise a lot with PC Gamer.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

This list is flawed badly- clearly.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

[ QUOTE ][*](26) Quake[*](

[/ QUOTE ]

What a disrespectfully low ranking.
the horror.. the horror

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

I also think this list sucks, but remember this is PC Gamer. No Final Fantasy, Tecmo Bowl etc. because this is a list of computer games.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

How can there not be a Papyrus racing game on that list?

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

[ QUOTE ]
Some ridiculous inclusions (Beavis & Butt-Head in Virtual Stupidity - give me a break) and some glaring omissions (none of the Final Fantasy games, Tetris, Halo, no Mario games, Techmo Bowl just off the top of my head). I would bet most of the publishers on the list advertise a lot with PC Gamer.

[/ QUOTE ]

Umm... Mario?

Umm... Final Fanstasy?

This is PC Gamer. Console games don't count.

Some of the FF games have been on PC, but they were ported badly. B&B they say is because it's the funniest adventure game ever. I can't really agree, but the fact that you mentioned Mario tells me a lot. [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]

Also, I agree with leaving Halo for PC off the list. [img]/images/graemlins/blush.gif[/img]


{EDIT}
I see someone else already corrected you.
Oops.

Re: PC Gamer\'s Top 50 Games of All-Time
 

[ QUOTE ]
Not sure how BF1942 got so high, Call of Duty is a better game and Return to Castle Wolfenstein was better than both, particulary multiplayer.

[/ QUOTE ]

Agreed.

Lawrence