Baptism troubles????

[easypete]

OK... here's the situation (since I qualify for J on Sklansky's religion quiz, I feel unqualified to answer it):

Father In-Law: Baptised Catholic
Brother In-Law: Baptised Catholic
Nephew (son of Brother In-Law): to be baptised as Baptist.

Father In-Law notifies us that this is a big problem for the future pro poker player (currently 3 - just starting to work on implied odds), but doesn't explain why.

A. Is the kid eternally damned?
B. Will the kid burst into flames (baptism by fire)?
C. It doesn't matter, because there is no god and all religion is superstitious behavior?
D. Other (explain)