Exactly. They're correct in points where they agree with Catholicism, incorrect where they conflict with Catholicism.

I believe that's what I said.

And I still don't understand why, to an outside observer, a Muslim or Hindu saying the exact same thing would be any different to you. Do you wish to elaborate?

[ QUOTE ]
4. Also, to someone who grew up without contact from these religions, what compelling reasons can you offer to follow one religion to the exclusion of the other four?

[/ QUOTE ]

edit: Just to clarify, what objective criteria would you use to determine the truth of one religion over another? What would you offer under these criteria to someone trying to decide? This is not specific to Catholicism.