A set vs. a made straight - when should I draw for the full house?

MP3 is 56.7/0/0.73 over 30 hands
UTG+2 is 56.5/0/0.45 over 23 hands

Both basically fish.

Paradise Poker No-Limit Hold'em, $50 (10 handed) converter (http://www.selachian.com/tools/bisonconverter/hhconverter.cgi)

CO ($53.50)
Hero ($50.00)
SB ($16.00)
BB ($44.50)
UTG ($27.75)
UTG+1 ($28.25)
UTG+2 ($60.25)
MP1 ($39.50)
MP2 ($41.25)
MP3 ($22.25)

Preflop: Hero is Button with 8/images/graemlins/heart.gif, 8/images/graemlins/club.gif. SB posts a blind of $0.25.
<font color="#666666">2 folds</font>, UTG+2 calls $0.50, <font color="#666666">2 folds</font>, MP3 calls $0.50, CO calls $0.50, Hero calls $0.50, SB (poster) completes, BB checks.

Flop: ($3) J/images/graemlins/diamond.gif, Q/images/graemlins/spade.gif, 8/images/graemlins/spade.gif <font color="#0000FF">(6 players)</font>
SB checks, BB checks, <font color="#CC3333">UTG+2 bets $1.5</font>, MP3 calls $1.50, CO folds, <font color="#CC3333">Hero raises to $3</font>, SB folds, BB folds, UTG+2 calls $1.50, <font color="#CC3333">MP3 raises to $4.5</font>, Hero calls $1.50, UTG+2 calls $1.50.

Turn: ($16.50) 9/images/graemlins/spade.gif <font color="#0000FF">(3 players)</font>
<font color="#CC3333">UTG+2 bets $8</font>, <font color="#CC3333">MP3 raises to $17.25</font>, Hero folds, UTG+2 calls $9.25.

River: ($51) Q/images/graemlins/diamond.gif <font color="#0000FF">(2 players)</font>

Final Pot: $51

I figure I'm beat after I get re-raised, but I call as it's not too much. On the turn I'm sure UTG+2 is going to call MP3's bet, bringing the pot to $51, pots odds say I should call (26%, 10 outs to win + 2 split the pot), UTG+2 has me covered and didn't want to risk another re-raise so I folded. Is it appropriate to make a call in this situation?

-thehof

[swolfe]

raise much more on the flop when it gets to you. pot sized raise makes it $9 to go.

the rest of your question is just pot odds. on the turn, you're getting, at best, 3:1 on a 4:1 shot, so folding is correct.

also, there's no way you can count split outs since one of these guys is likely to have a flush.

even if you hit it, someone may hold QQ JJ 99 QJ Q9 Q8 TJspades

Good point, I was basing the split pot on information I got from Poker Tracker after I knew what the cards were. Both players had the straight UTG+2 had AT (no black cards) and MP3 had 9T (no black cards) and he had flopped the straight.