PDA

View Full Version : 100 films: The Godfather


pryor15
11-25-2005, 02:38 AM
http://www.free-times.com/artwork/070704/Brando.jpg
NOTE: Part 2 is coming in a few hours as part of my Thankgiving tradition of watching the entire series.

starring: Marlon Brando, Al Pacino, James Caan, Robert Duvall, Diane Keaton, Richard S. Castellano, Talia Shire, and John Cazale
written by: Mario Puzo and Francis Ford Coppola, from the novel by Puzo
directed by: Francis Ford Coppola
R, 175 min, 1972, USA

The great Shakespearian epic of our time, The Godfather series is perhaps the grandest accomplishment in the history of American cinema. It made stars of several actors and director Francis Ford Coppola, was nominated for a total of 29 Academy Awards, won Best Picture twice, and has inspired numerous entries in the popular lexicon. Part one tells the story of how Michael Corleone (Al Pacino), a civilian war hero, is trust into the family business he said he'd never join and ascends to the throne of the empire.

In retrospect it's hard to imagine, but Paramount was not in favor of Coppola's cast choices for any of the major roles. Coppola set his sights on Brando and Pacino, in particular, early in the process and would not budge as the studio brought in essentially every "name" actor in the greater Los Angeles area to read for the parts[1]. The concern was that Brando was too far gone as an actor and that Pacino had no name recognition, but as usually happens in these scenarios, the director was right and both actors turned in fantastic performances. Brando's Vito Corleone would earn him a Best Actor Oscar[2], as well as inspire a littany of impressions with his raspy delivery. Al Pacino has the most difficult role in the film, as he must portray a transformation from a character with a basic sense of purity to a calculating monster who would have his godson's father murdered on the day of the christening. We see the first steps of this evolution when Michael visits his father in the hospital only to find the guards have been ordered to leave. He springs to action, moving his father and standing up to the corrupt police chief who tries to arrest him. The certainty of his actions speaks volumes about his nature, much more than the speeches he uses to convince himself he's not like his father. He cannot deny that this is part of who he is, it's too deeply ingrained to ignore, and from that moment on he is fully involved. In a memorable scene that may just be the finest moment of Pacino's career, he guns down the police captain and the man who tried to kill his father in a restaurant. Although he may spend the rest of the films striving to regain his legitimacy, his actions over the course of those two days seals his fate.

Francis Ford Coppola is a man heavily steeped in the importance of family and the Italian way of life, and he uses those convictions to really give the film the proper dynamic. He understands how these large families operate, how the various relationships play off each other, and he employs his experiences to add a authentic feel to the proceedings. It's the small things, like adding wine to the pasta recipe, or the importance of operation a Sicilian courtship through the extended family, that sells large chunks of the film. The visual flair of the film is further defined by cinematographer Gordon Willis. The shots he composes are truly a thing of beauty. His is a name too often forgotten when discussing the great film artists.

*************
[1] Including Robert DeNiro, who read for multiple parts and would later play the young Vito in The Godfather: Part II

[2] It was his second win against 8 nominations (the last coming in 1989 for A Dry White Season). He famously sent Sacheen Littlefeather to the ceremony in his place to protest discrimination against Native Americans. Ironically, Littlefeather was just an actor.

Colonel Kataffy
11-25-2005, 02:44 AM
I liked it too. /images/graemlins/smile.gif

kipin
11-25-2005, 02:45 AM
Very nice, I'm glad to see someone else watches these flicks on Thanksgiving. (Although I have not gotten around to it this year.)

This movie was confusing for me to follow the first time I watched it, but I was still able to appreciate how captivating the entire story is.

I will probably watch it later tonight as I fall asleep.

MonkeeMan
11-25-2005, 02:48 AM
You forgot the cannoli /images/graemlins/smile.gif

nice post.

Blarg
11-25-2005, 06:59 AM
Great, great film. Easily one of the very top candidates of the whole century for film most likely to be remembered hundreds of years from now.

diebitter
11-25-2005, 07:09 AM
Okay, I achknowledge Godfather and Godfather 2 are great movies, among the top, but I've cooled to them over time.

I could watch em over and over again, but I have a problem with them. I find them a little cold and a bit like a wonderfully-shot, beautifully-composed soap opera...

There's so little energy in em, is the problem. Charisma and mood are there in abundance, but energy... nah! Only James Caan really brings force to the screen, and so much so he nearly topples the mood, but his shooting sorts that out. There's some energy and life from Diane Keaton too, but to a much lesser extent. De Niro is dynamic and obviously forceful in his quiet way too, but even he comes across as subdued. Pacino - great role and portrays the complexity of his character extraordinarily well - but too much thinking, not enough passion...


Listen, I like these films a lot too, but only in the admiration/beautiful film making way - same with Citizen Kane. Like is the operative word here. I LIKE em.

The difference is I LOVE Christmas Story, Groundhog Day, Aliens, Live and Let Die, Bride of Frankenstein, The Producers, Empire Strikes Back, Pulp Fiction, Lock Stock, Sleepy Hollow blah blah blah.

Hell, I even love 'Plan 9 from Outer Space'. It's like loving your goldfish, I know, but love is love, right?

Great film having said all that, great review as always.

Blarg
11-25-2005, 07:54 AM
Jeez, the whole shooting of the Turk and the police captain scene in the restaurant is nail-biting and very cool.

The scene where Brando handles the mortician who wants him to kill his daughter's rapist is full of tension and you can really feel the guy's pain and anger. The Don's processing of it and coming to a good solution was pretty cool and showed a lot of the competence with people and situations that let you know how this guy got this high in his world.

And the scene in the hospital where Michael has to protect his father was brilliant to me. I was on pins and needles there. And his confrontation with the crooked cop outside the hospital definitely got me involved -- and pissed off! This was a really great passage, I thought.

Granted, it was stolen from "M", but the ironic intercutting of the baptism with the murders was telling and fun. The horse's head in the bed thing was brilliant and people were talking about it all the time for the next 20 years.

The shooting of Sony, and the old man's regret, was fantastic. His beating of Carlo was great -- it was even parodied on the Simpsons, it was such an icon of ass kicking.

The scene were Luca Brasi gets his hand stabbed to the bar was outrageous!

When consigliere Tom Hagen gets picked up off the street by the Turk after Brando gets shot and never really knows if he's going to be killed or not is very gripping.

The lonely sadness of the execution by the side of the road while Pauli casually takes a piss in the cornfield and stares off into the distance was moving to me. What a way to go.

Sheesh -- so many good scenes! And the family feel of it, the betrayal by Tessio, the beauty of Michael's virgin bride and her horrible death, the creepiness of Barzini...just so good, all of it.

The only thing that bogged down for me was when Keaton was on screen. Her well-meaning but fairly flat well bred pallor was a sort of pacing between the higher voltage goings-on among all these more red-blooded crazies, so it served a dramatic purpose, but she didn't have a lot of screen dynamism. It was easy to see her as more and more irrelevant and unappealing, and the part I want to get past so I can get to the good stuff.

Really, Coppola (with the help of Mario Puzo) creates a very rich world that feels very lived in and credible and interesting. I was definitely happily along for the ride the very first time I saw it, and every time since.

diebitter
11-25-2005, 08:00 AM
Hell, I know I'm in the minority here - we're all allowed our little quirks.

Well, I do like it lots and lots, but only as a friend. True Romance or similar, on the other hand, I'm all over like a rash /images/graemlins/grin.gif

Blarg
11-25-2005, 08:04 AM
I almost peed when you said you loved things like Empire Strikes Back and Sleepy Hollow, but not Godfather.

We each have our own things that grip others but somehow miss the mark with us, though.

But liking Aliens better than Alien is still grounds for a verbal ass-whipping.

diebitter
11-25-2005, 08:09 AM
[ QUOTE ]
I almost peed when you said you loved things like Empire Strikes Back and Sleepy Hollow, but not Godfather.

We each have our own things that grip others but somehow miss the mark with us, though.

But liking Aliens better than Alien is still grounds for a verbal ass-whipping.

[/ QUOTE ]

Oh Blarg, love is love! You can't rationalise it, you just feel it.

Okay? Okay!

And from your statement, I think we agree on that.

Oh, and I love Alien too. If I spouted off all the films I love off the top of my head, there'd be 2 consequences...

1) It would get really old really quick
2) I'd overlook something fabulous, and it would get jealous...


/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Blarg
11-25-2005, 08:33 AM
And if I didn't needle you sometimes, you'd get sloppy. That's how it starts. And then one day some punk walks into a saloon, looking to make a name for himself, and you, you've been thinking you weren't what you are anymore for so long you actually come to believe it, and think anyone cares. You get to thinking time washed the stink away and it couldn't pull the wolves out of the dark anymore, wouldn't follow you to your grave. And that's when you get a bullet in the back of the head, because you thought you could turn and walk away from what you were. That it wouldn't be staring you straight in the face for the rest of your life.

Hombre, it doesn't work that way. Once you become an OOT gunslinger, you're a marked man, and some jittery corn-fed punk will always be looking to make a name for himself off your pooper. Your breed sits with its back to a wall for the rest of its life.

diebitter
11-25-2005, 08:43 AM
My friend, I was born ready.

I bin a man since forever, and a man may have only rocks to plough, but it's his job to plough them.

We'll leave the crying and lamenting to the women. We got work to be doing. The plough don't push itself.

Cyrus
11-25-2005, 09:02 AM
[ QUOTE ]
There's so little energy in em, is the problem. Charisma and mood are there in abundance, but energy... nah! Only James Caan really brings force to the screen, and so much so he nearly topples the mood, but his shooting sorts that out.

[/ QUOTE ]
Music with continuous crescendos fires up the testosterone but this gets your balls to do your thinking instead of your heart. Thinking from the heart is the objective. Godfather is full of tension. Intra-family relations are as tense as the family is close. Release of the tension, by beating up the sister's husband (an outsider), is momentary and not cathartic. Catharsis is reserved for moments of grander resolution, such as the confrontation between husband and wife over the fate of the kids -- or the elimination of All My Enemies On Earth.

Methinks we should be able to appreciate a musical piece with ups and downs, refrains and bridges, various instruments and humans behind the music, feeling, thinking and speaking.

diebitter
11-25-2005, 09:06 AM
...but I still don't LOVE it. and as love is subjective by definition, no amount of words is gonna change that.

That doesn't mean I don't have enourmous respect for it as a giant of cinema though.

Blarg
11-25-2005, 09:06 AM
I had to read your post twice to catch it fully, but think it makes a good point and was well said.

Vavavoom
11-30-2005, 05:07 PM
I didn't want to bump this right to the top...but I watched this film for the first time today !

WOW !!!! Thats all I have to say....I'm going to watch 2 & 3 in the coming days....

Wow JUST WOW !!!!!

Brainwalter
11-30-2005, 05:26 PM
[ QUOTE ]
I didn't want to bump this right to the top...but I watched this film for the first time today !

WOW !!!! Thats all I have to say....I'm going to watch 2 & 3 in the coming days....

Wow JUST WOW !!!!!

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah dude, this is my favorite movie.