Is It Just Me?

[John Cole]

Or did Bush's remarks on combatting bird flu sound very much like his remarks on fighting terrorism?

Another shot with no substance. Jeeze, can you not make your point(s) in some small resemblance to a case?

"Where's tha' beef?"

[Autocratic]

[ QUOTE ]
Another shot with no substance. Jeeze, can you not make your point(s) in some small resemblance to a case?

"Where's tha' beef?"

[/ QUOTE ]

Noting similarities in rhetorical technique may not be pertinent to you, but I'm sure some people would find it interesting.

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Another shot with no substance. Jeeze, can you not make your point(s) in some small resemblance to a case?

"Where's tha' beef?"

[/ QUOTE ]

Noting similarities in rhetorical technique may not be pertinent to you, but I'm sure some people would find it interesting.

[/ QUOTE ]


Whulllll, golllleeeeeee, Sparky, ex-cuuuu-uuuuse me!

[Myrtle]

[ QUOTE ]
Or did Bush's remarks on combatting bird flu sound very much like his remarks on fighting terrorism?

[/ QUOTE ]

....if it waddles like a duck, sounds like a duck, and looks like a duck....

quack.....quack. /images/graemlins/smirk.gif

[John Cole]

[ QUOTE ]
if it waddles like a duck, sounds like a duck, and looks like a duck....

[/ QUOTE ]

it's a Rhode Island Red?

[John Cole]

I wasn't attempting "to make a case." Nor did I realize I was required to do so. However, I think if you hear his remarks, and substitute "terrorism" for "flu," you may be somewhat surprised at the general tenor and tone. For example, regarding the flu: "We have been given fair warning." By whom? By what? The first part of the plan calls for containment in the country of origin, with funds allocated to help natives deal with the outbreak.

[tomdemaine]

[ QUOTE ]
The first part of the plan calls for containment in the country of origin, with funds allocated to help natives deal with the outbreak.

[/ QUOTE ]

Damn thats so dumb. We should just let the free market deal with it.

[Myrtle]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
if it waddles like a duck, sounds like a duck, and looks like a duck....

[/ QUOTE ]

it's a Rhode Island Red?

[/ QUOTE ]

I thought all of the roosters in Rhode Island drowed during last months deluge?

[Dynasty]

I'm still trying to figure out why this is such a big story.

Nobody has gotten this flu in the U.S. And, there have been recent reports which even say no bird has this flu.


I suppose, if you wanted to be a political hack, you could point out how many Democrats (Kennedy, Hillary) are crying "the sky is falling" on this flu yet critcize Bush when he is perceived to do the same thing concerning terrorism.

[ QUOTE ]
I wasn't attempting "to make a case." Nor did I realize I was required to do so. However, I think if you hear his remarks, and substitute "terrorism" for "flu," you may be somewhat surprised at the general tenor and tone. For example, regarding the flu: "We have been given fair warning." By whom? By what? The first part of the plan calls for containment in the country of origin, with funds allocated to help natives deal with the outbreak.

[/ QUOTE ]


Your non-attempt at making a case was apparent. You think maybe that had something to do with my post?

I haven't read the FAQ or TOS lately, but I'm pretty sure there's no requirement for you to make any kind of case. But, when I see a thread started in the manner you chose (lack of content), that motivates me to make the type of reply I did.

Now that you've put some substance into the thread I have an opportunity to understand what you seemed to think I should have inferred.

Every politician uses speech writers. Not all politicians are good at delivering speeches. I don't think GWB has a staff of great writers. We all know he's never going to be considered one of the great orators. I suspect his writers sometimes pull out old stuff and change it to fit the occasion. I've noticed other pols, at times, apparently doing the same.

I only heard part of the "Avian Flu" speech. Frankly, I got bored. Also, I really hate to see the man screw up a speech like he seems to, frequently.

The warning he mentioned came, in part, from the people he was speaking in front of. The NIH. Argue if you will as to their credentials and/or expertise.

If action isn't taken in the countries of origin, where should it be? Only in the affected regions? You don't wait for Mad Cow disease to reach Texas when the sick cattle are in Europe, do you?

This is another of those "damned if you do and damned if you don't" situations. If he "gets out in front" and takes action he's accused of being overly cautious and hasty. (or recycling speeches) If he waits for a pandemic he'll be accused of genocide, or neglect, or being un-caring, or anything his detractors can come up with.

[Zeno]

[ QUOTE ]
Or did Bush's remarks on combatting bird flu sound very much like his remarks on fighting terrorism?

[/ QUOTE ]

I have a dream: It is a fervent wish and hope that both terrorism and the bird flu reduce the world population by 80% within the next decade.

Le Misanthrope

[andyfox]

Politics. Just like the "stunt" Reid pulled yesterday. I'm not saying Reid doesn't care about the second part of the Intelligence Committee report, or that Bush doesn't care about protecting us from the possible spread of the Avian Flu, but it became a big story because Bush needed a big story to show he's being proactive in addressing a problem, and because he needed a counterheadling to the Reid and Libby stories. SOB (Standard Operation BS).

[John Cole]

BTW, I wasn't bashing Bush for his speaking prowess. (Hell, if I were called upon to do what he does, I'd doubt I could pull it off. And I do realize that he uses speechwriters.)

Instead, and the only reason for my post, I was struck by the similarity between the rhetoric concerning terrorism and the "threat" of Avian Flu. (How much of a threat it represents, I have no knowledge of.) I think I'll reread "Politics and the English Language."

[cdxx]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Another shot with no substance. Jeeze, can you not make your point(s) in some small resemblance to a case?

"Where's tha' beef?"

[/ QUOTE ]

Noting similarities in rhetorical technique may not be pertinent to you, but I'm sure some people would find it interesting.

[/ QUOTE ]

i noticed that in outlining both of his strategies on terrorism and the avian flu, Bush used lots of words. I many instances he used the same words, such as "the", "and", etc.

p.s. this is not the least bit interesting to me. it's interesting what exactly his strategies involve.

[elwoodblues]

[ QUOTE ]
i noticed that in outlining both of his strategies on terrorism and the avian flu, Bush used lots of words. I many instances he used the same words, such as "the", "and", etc.


[/ QUOTE ]

zing

[John Cole]

Why don't you lest us know what else you have no interest in? /images/graemlins/grin.gif

[andyfox]

Shouldn't that be: Why don't you let us know in what else you have no interest?

[John Cole]

Andy,

I'm jes tryin' to talk like them common folk.