Running Fantasy Football draft rating thread

[hoyaboy1]

I'll start /images/graemlins/grin.gif If you ask for a rating, make sure you comment on other peoples' drafts.

10 team league, QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, DEF, K, standard scoring. I had the 1st pick.

1. (1) L. Tomlinson
2. (20) R. Johnson
3. (21) T. Holt
4. (40) K. Collins
5. (41) J. Witten
6. (60) C. Chambers
7. (61) D. Mason
8. (80) K. Barlow
9. (81) C. Benson
10. (100) L. Evans
11. (101) Buffalo
12. (120) D. Carr
13. (121) E. Kennison
14. (140) M. Faulk
15. (141) C. Rogers

I am not that happy with 4 and 5 - but the elite RBs were gone, and I thought I could get WRs of similar value later, which i think I did. Still doesn't look right. I'll try to make a trade before the season and use the space to get a kicker.

[brettbrettr]

[ QUOTE ]

1. (1) L. Tomlinson --good
2. (20) R. Johnson -good
3. (21) T. Holt -good
4. (40) K. Collins - not good
5. (41) J. Witten -eh
6. (60) C. Chambers -eh, qb troubles, but I guess its ok
7. (61) D. Mason --good
8. (80) K. Barlow --good
9. (81) C. Benson --good
10. (100) L. Evans --Go Badgers.
11. (101) Buffalo --defense sucks
12. (120) D. Carr --nice
13. (121) E. Kennison --fine
14. (140) M. Faulk --fine
15. (141) C. Rogers --good


[/ QUOTE ]

[hoyaboy1]

Buffalo's defense does not suck. At all.

Edit - unless you meant I picked a D too early, which is possible. But I thought Buffalo's D was a lot better than those left, and didn't think that about any other available positions.

[wh1t3bread]

Looks pretty good. I think you took Collins 1 round too early and Witten a round or 2 too early. Taking a defense (no matter how good) that early was probably a mistake.

I like your QB situation and your RB situation. Your first 3 picks were pretty good. Solid team overall I think.

[brettbrettr]

[ QUOTE ]
Buffalo's defense does not suck. At all.

[/ QUOTE ]

I meant all defenses suck. Every year I pick one up witha a good week one match-up. Then I grab another in week 2. Then I keep them all year because they're good all year. Wasting picks on D is bad tho, unless you find the Ravens available late or something...

[SossMan]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

1. (1) L. Tomlinson --good
2. (20) R. Johnson -good
3. (21) T. Holt -good
4. (40) K. Collins - not good
5. (41) J. Witten -eh
6. (60) C. Chambers -eh, qb troubles, but I guess its ok
7. (61) D. Mason --good
8. (80) K. Barlow --good
9. (81) C. Benson --good
10. (100) L. Evans --Go Badgers.
11. (101) Buffalo --defense sucks
12. (120) D. Carr --nice
13. (121) E. Kennison --fine
14. (140) M. Faulk --fine
15. (141) C. Rogers --good


[/ QUOTE ]

[/ QUOTE ]

[morello]

First three picks are good. I don't like the Kerry Collins pick that much.

Witten is a good pick IMO. Only one TD last year, I think he will grab much more this year.

The Chambers and Barlow picks are pretty "meh" to me.

[imported_anacardo]

Witten had like 6 touchdowns last year. I took joy in them all, as a Dallas fan + former owner.

[brettbrettr]

[ QUOTE ]
Witten had like 6 touchdowns last year. I took joy in them all, as a Dallas fan + former owner.

[/ QUOTE ]

HOld on. Syntax. You're a fantasy owner of the one Jason Witten or real life owner of the Dallas Cowboys?

[morello]

[ QUOTE ]
Witten had like 6 touchdowns last year. I took joy in them all, as a Dallas fan + former owner.

[/ QUOTE ]

Whoops, you are correct. Clearly I don't know how to read.

But whatever, Witten is still a good pickup.

[CD56]

I think this draft looks solid, i like a lot of the later RB pickups.

In general though it's tough to comment on someones performance in a draft without knowing the whole of the draft. You can kinda eyeball it on a round by round basis, but without knowing what was still out there when you picked a particular player, how can anyone really comment on whether or not it was a good pick.

[SossMan]

I think it's safe to say that if someone takes TB def/st in the 6th round, that's bad.

[Sluss]

[ QUOTE ]
10 team league, QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, DEF, K, standard scoring. I had the 1st pick.

1. (1) L. Tomlinson Duh
2. (20) R. Johnson Good second back
3. (21) T. Holt Nice Value
4. (40) K. Collins will be alright
5. (41) J. Witten alright maybe a round too early
6. (60) C. Chambers meh, about three rounds too early
7. (61) D. Mason uh, Kyle Boller throwing to him, I hope you get points for returns /images/graemlins/confused.gif
8. (80) K. Barlow Not a bad 8th round pick
9. (81) C. Benson Could be good by the middle of the season
10. (100) L. Evans not bad value, Should be Losman's #1 target whatever that's worth
11. (101) Buffalo huh? WHY!?
12. (120) D. Carr Wow, well your lucky he was still around nice value
13. (121) E. Kennison okay
14. (140) M. Faulk what the heck, could get a Bus second half nice late gamble
15. (141) C. Rogers If he stays healthy he's very good Another nice late gambling pick


[/ QUOTE ]