12-09-2001, 10:17 PM
I was playing in a home game with some friends that I had never played with before and this situation came up a few hours in. We play Dealer's Choice, and inevitbly, one guys feels the need to play 7-card stud (8's and 9's are wild). At the showdown, the 2 remaining players turn over Royal Flushes.
Player 1: Ac, 8h, 9s, Jc, 10c
Player 2: 9d, Ks, Qs, Js, 9h
The way I saw it, it should have been a chopped pot... but a few of the players insisted that since Player 1 had the highest natural card (Ac) that the pot was his. (one said that the player's highest natural card was as high as his hand could be...meaning Player 2 actually had a K-high straight flush).
What's the consensus out there? Are these 2 the same hand? Or is this an example of a rule variation that we should make clear to players a the beginning of the night. In this case, it was about a $120 pot, and wanting to keep the game friendly, the guy with Ac decided to split the pot.
Player 1: Ac, 8h, 9s, Jc, 10c
Player 2: 9d, Ks, Qs, Js, 9h
The way I saw it, it should have been a chopped pot... but a few of the players insisted that since Player 1 had the highest natural card (Ac) that the pot was his. (one said that the player's highest natural card was as high as his hand could be...meaning Player 2 actually had a K-high straight flush).
What's the consensus out there? Are these 2 the same hand? Or is this an example of a rule variation that we should make clear to players a the beginning of the night. In this case, it was about a $120 pot, and wanting to keep the game friendly, the guy with Ac decided to split the pot.