PDA

View Full Version : Cecil Fielder sues papers for $25-mil


MicroBob
12-07-2004, 07:42 PM
Follow-up to the October stories about Cecil's gambling-losses which many around here seemed to be interested in.

Looks like Cecil is trying to cash-in on the damage his "reputation" took.


http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/baseball/201761_fielder01.html


Ex-slugger Fielder files libel suit over stories

By CURTIS EICHELBERGER
BLOOMBERG NEWS

DETROIT -- Former major leaguer Cecil Fielder sued the publisher of Detroit's two daily newspapers for libel and slander over a series of articles that said he lost $47 million through bad investments and gambling.

Fielder -- who played 13 seasons with the Detroit Tigers, New York Yankees, Anaheim Angels, Toronto Blue Jays and Cleveland Indians -- also sued his real estate agent and reporter Fred Girard, who wrote the stories for the Detroit News. The suit claimed Fielder's privacy was invaded and that he was placed in a false light.

Fielder said in the suit that he suffered more than $25 million in damages "as a result of defendant's actions." He's seeking compensatory and punitive damages. Attorneys for the Detroit Newspaper Agency, which operates Gannett Co.'s Detroit News, and its competitor, Knight-Ridder Inc.'s Detroit Free Press, could not immediately be reached.

In the first story, which ran Oct. 17 under the headline, "Gambling Shatters Ex-Tiger's Dream Life," Girard cited New Jersey Superior Court records that showed Fielder lost $580,000 at Trump Plaza Hotel and Casino in Atlantic City during one 40-hour period in February 1999.

The article also quoted real estate agent Al Arostegui, who claimed Fielder and his wife owed him $70,000 for advertising the family's 50-room Florida home for sale.

In a subsequent story that ran Oct. 21, Girard quoted Fielder's son, Prince, saying that he and his sister Ceclynn wanted to file for a divorce from their father. Prince Fielder, who signed with the Milwaukee Brewers and is in the team's minor league system, told the newspaper that his father kept $200,000 of his $2.4 million signing bonus.

Cecil Fielder, a three-time All-Star first baseman, had a career .255 batting average and hit 319 homers.

PokerPaul
12-08-2004, 11:39 AM
hmmmm,

wonder what kind of case he might have, because as far as i know there is nothing illegal about reporting anything truthful.

So unless the real estate agent or reporters were lying, i doubt he will get anything but a fat lawyer bill out of this.

Unless of course the papers embellished the real story to much.

Michael Davis
12-09-2004, 02:12 AM
You're not even liable if you report false information as long as there is "absence of malice."

-Michael

GuyOnTilt
12-09-2004, 06:58 AM
i doubt he will get anything but a fat lawyer bill out of this.

Settlement.

GoT

MicroBob
12-09-2004, 08:45 AM
Agree.

Considering the extraordinary amount he is suing for the horrible 'damage' that his reputation took it looks pretty much like he saw an opportunity to try to make some of that lost money back and jumped on it.


Uh-oh....maybe he's going to sue me now for further damage to his reputation.

Sorry Cecil. I'm a decent poker player...but i don't have $25-mil. Maybe you'll want to wait until AFTER I win the WSOP to sue me.

MrDannimal
12-09-2004, 06:04 PM
I'm not sure. Newspapers (legit ones, not the tabloids) are the least likely to settle, I'd think. They are pretty adament about defending the right to report news with as little restriction as possible. Settling would mean that anytime you published a negative story about an athlete (or celebrity), you'd have to cough up $$.